Today, my friend Autumn did a post titled God and Adoption that she wrote in response to a post a friend of hers wrote yesterday titled the same. Those two posts prompted this one. I hope you stop by and read their posts. If you can only read one, read this one. It is worth your time. My post is not a post on adoption. I don't feel I have the right to write that post because I was not adopted and I do not have adoptive children, nor did I give my children up for adoption. But this is my post; this is my response to their posts.
Plan A vs. Plan B: Which is Better?
First we will look at my life, my childhood. I am not going to go into details here.
Plan A would be for me to have been born into a loving, stable family. I didn't get Plan A.
Instead, I was born into the home of a self-focused adult survivor of abuse who chose to use drugs and continue the cycle of abuse. I bounced from her home to foster care to the home of my Great-Aunt and Great-Uncle, lovingly called Grandma and Grandpa.
Plan B could have been for the state to sever the rights of my mother. It would have been better for me to grow up in a group home than to grow up like I did.
An alternate Plan B could have been for the foster parents who loved me when I was 6 to have been allowed to adopt me. They would have. I know they would have because they had several former foster children who had become forever theirs.
Another Plan B could have been for my Grandparents to do what it took to make the temporary custody they had become permanent. For them to keep me from year to year instead of sending me back.
There is nothing you could say to convince me that the horrors I experienced as a child are anywhere related to God's desire for my life. That is not to say that I do not believe God used what I went through to make me who I am today. I believe He did and I believe I will never fully comprehend the horrors I did not suffer because He was protecting me even before I knew Him personally. But the life I lived was not Plan A and any one of the Plan B's out there would have been better.
For my kids, Plan A is again for them to be born into a loving, stable family. My kids didn't get Plan A, either.
Don't get me wrong, I am a good mom and I know that. I love my kids and would do anything for them. But Plan A is for them to have a loving, stable family. I was not able to give them stability for a long time. The only part of their life that was stable was that we were together.
Plan B would have been for me to give them up for adoption. I didn't and I am glad I didn't.
They only have one parent; one loving parent, but still only one. Two is better.
From my sketchy description of my childhood, it could easily be assumed that I had some learning to do on what it means to be a good parent and how to get there. Who do you think suffered the consequences of my mistakes?
We do without a lot of things. This is not all bad. Sometimes, it is. My kids don't remember, but they have been homeless. That is bad for kids. Again, they don't remember, but there have been many times I was not sure I could feed them. God always provided, but that is still not good, not Plan A.
We have moved a lot. We moved more than most military families I know. This is not good for kids.
I guess we are living in between Plan A and Plan B. Maybe my grandchildren will get Plan A.
So, which is better?
In my case, Plan B, hands down. Some people just shouldn't be parents. My mother is one of those people.
In my girls' case, this place we are living, inching closer to Plan A every day, is best. But it takes a lot of effort. It takes a lot of support from people around me. It takes friends stepping up to remind me I am a good mom. It takes people being willing to give me a day off from the pressures of being everything to my kids all the time. It takes a good church. It takes financial support, more than I can muster on my own, sometimes from the government, sometimes from the church, sometimes from individuals. It takes faith. But most of all, it takes commitment from me to do the right thing, to not only be a mother, but a good mom.
Plan A is usually better, except for when it is completely unattainable. Adoption is the best Plan B there is. It provides children with what they don't get when their Plan A fails. There. That's my ambiguous answer.